SnitchFeed vs ReplyGuy
Verified against ReplyGuy's own site, September 2026
These are adjacent products that look similar in a feature list and solve different problems. ReplyGuy is a reply tool: it finds conversations so you can respond to them, and on most tiers it will post for you. SnitchFeed is a monitoring tool: it watches five platforms and routes what matters into your workflow. The overlap is their Analyst tier, and that is where the real comparison lives.
Who each tool is actually for
ReplyGuy is for getting your product mentioned in conversations
Find relevant threads on Reddit and X, draft a reply, post it. Reply tiers run from $10 a month for 20 replies up to $199 a month for 1,000. There is also an Analyst tier at $39 that strips out the replies and sells the monitoring on its own, with 20 keywords and 5 projects.
SnitchFeed is for knowing what is being said, everywhere it matters
Reddit, X, LinkedIn, Bluesky and Hacker News, with AI relevance and intent scoring, and routing into Slack and Discord, or webhooks on Pro. We surface conversations and help you decide which are worth your time. We do not post on your behalf.
SnitchFeed or ReplyGuy?
Choose ReplyGuy if
Founders and marketers whose goal is to get their product mentioned in Reddit and X conversations, on a small budget.
- Reddit and X are the only platforms you care about
- You want help writing replies, not just finding threads
- You are comfortable with automated posting, or you want the cheap monitoring-only tier
- You are working alone rather than as a team
Choose SnitchFeed if
B2B teams who need to know what is being said across five platforms and act on it together.
- You need LinkedIn, Bluesky or Hacker News as well as Reddit and X
- You would rather nothing posted under your brand automatically
- More than one person needs to see and work the same mentions
- You want mentions scored for intent, not just matched on keywords
- You want alerts in Slack rather than another tool to check
What it costs
Compared against ReplyGuy's Analyst tier, the one that overlaps with what we do. Their reply tiers are a different product and are listed for context rather than compared.
| Comparison | ReplyGuy | SnitchFeed |
|---|---|---|
| Monitoring-only tier, month to month | $39/month (Analyst), 20 keywords, 5 projects | $59/month (Starter), 10 keywords |
| Monitoring-only tier, billed annually | $199/year for Analyst, about $17/month | $47/month |
| Platforms | Reddit and X | Reddit, X, LinkedIn, Bluesky, Hacker News |
| Cheapest tier overall | $10/month (Small), 5 keywords, 20 replies | $59/month |
| Automated replies | Included on every tier except Analyst, 20 to 1,000 per month | None. We draft on request; we never post for you. |
Where ReplyGuy is genuinely better
All of this is true. If any of it is a requirement rather than a preference, buy ReplyGuy.
Considerably cheaper, and it is not close on the annual axis
Analyst is $199 a year, roughly $17 a month, against our $47. Even month to month it is $39 with 20 keywords against our $59 with 10. If budget is the binding constraint and Reddit and X are all you need, they win this outright.
Reply drafting as a first-class workflow
Finding the conversation is half the job. ReplyGuy is built around the other half, drafting something worth posting, and it does that as its main purpose rather than as a side feature.
A $10 door
Their Small tier is $10 a month. We have nothing at that price and a lot of people want to spend $10 before they spend $59.
More keywords at the overlap tier
20 keywords on Analyst against our 10 on Starter, and 5 projects against our 3 listeners.
Where SnitchFeed beats ReplyGuy
The cases where we would tell you to pick us.
Three platforms they do not cover
LinkedIn, Bluesky and Hacker News. If your buyers are discussing tools on LinkedIn, no ReplyGuy tier will show you that conversation. For B2B teams this usually settles it.
We do not post on your behalf, by design
We do not automate posting on your brand's behalf. Automated replies and DMs put brand perception at serious risk and run against platform terms of service, and the account that gets actioned is yours, not the vendor's. We surface conversations, score them and route them to you, and you decide what to say and where. Some teams want the automation anyway, and that is a legitimate choice; we would rather be clear that it is not one we offer.
Built for a team, not a poster
Shared feeds, AI relevance and intent scoring, analytics, and alerts into Slack and Discord where the rest of your team already works. ReplyGuy's monitoring tier is a stripped-down version of a single-operator tool.
Real-time Reddit and Bluesky on every tier
Including Starter, with hourly refresh on X, LinkedIn and Hacker News.
Where these figures come from
ReplyGuy figures were checked against their own site in September 2026. Pricing changes; if you spot something out of date here, tell us and we will fix it.
Used and praised by
Loved by GTM teams
See what companies are actually saying about us.
I love SnitchFeed. Can't recommend it enough.
I really like what I achieved with SnitchFeed.
One dashboard. Every conversation that matters. No more hopping between platforms. Quality product & great founder 🤝
Anyone reading this comment, I've used SnitchFeed and loved it!
Spent 5 minutes on SnitchFeed, dropped a comment → new user
Just started using SnitchFeed and I'm already loving it. Great Work!
I love SnitchFeed. Can't recommend it enough.
I really like what I achieved with SnitchFeed.
One dashboard. Every conversation that matters. No more hopping between platforms. Quality product & great founder 🤝
Anyone reading this comment, I've used SnitchFeed and loved it!
Spent 5 minutes on SnitchFeed, dropped a comment → new user
Just started using SnitchFeed and I'm already loving it. Great Work!
I legit booked 5 meetings with SnitchFeed this week. And it's only Monday...
Does what it says on the tin. Quite well.
Every day I open my laptop, SnitchFeed is the first thing I log into.
Immediately found 5 perfect posts that I replied to on X & LinkedIn. Wasn't expecting that!
The ability to use AI sentiment scoring and get insights on data is incredibly useful. Very hard to find at this price point!
Super easy setup and UI. Actually delivers on what it promises to do.
I legit booked 5 meetings with SnitchFeed this week. And it's only Monday...
Does what it says on the tin. Quite well.
Every day I open my laptop, SnitchFeed is the first thing I log into.
Immediately found 5 perfect posts that I replied to on X & LinkedIn. Wasn't expecting that!
The ability to use AI sentiment scoring and get insights on data is incredibly useful. Very hard to find at this price point!
Super easy setup and UI. Actually delivers on what it promises to do.
High-signal mentions per month? (typically 200-300)
100
200
300
400
500
What's your conversion rate?
1% (very conservative)
3% (realistic)
5% (aggressive)
What's your average customer Lifetime Value (LTV)?
1000
3250
5500
7750
10000
How many hours will you save per month? (typically 20)
10
20
30
40
50
See SnitchFeed in Action
Watch how SnitchFeed helps you capture high-intent leads from social media and turn them into customers.
Ready to start capturing leads from social media?
Everything you need to know
Can't find what you're looking for? We're fast to respond.
Still have questions? Reach out at hello@snitchfeed.com
